Beatrice Caswell is enjoying her quiet vampire unlife, when freshly turned werewolf, Vic Montana, shows up at her door uninvited. Caswell reluctantly agrees to help Montana adjust to her new life, despite their noticeable differences. Caswell is prissy and traditional. Montana is easygoing and very much atypical. She even turns into a puppy instead of a wolf. While their friendship is slowly growing, they're discovered by local preteens.

Caswell slowly realizes she's got a crush on her werewolf compatriot. She admits this to the kids, who start setting up romantic scenarios to get the monster couple together. But Montana has bigger fish to fry, and things don't get easier when Brick turns up. He's the werewolf who turned Montana in the first place, and he hates vampires. With supernatural bad luck, a host of local oddballs, and ancient monster feuds on top of the regular relationship troubles, it's going to take a powerful kind of love for their special romance to survive.