On an autumn night in 2003, Jessi Johnson went missing while camping with a group of her best friends. Although no one seems to know where she went or how she got there, they don know that Jessi was hiding some pretty big secrets. However, when she's found dead close to her friend's family cabin, it's up to Detective Shane Holmes to find the person responsible for the 17-year-old's murder. After following the evidence, Detective Holmes catches his killer in what appears to be an open-and-shut case. But, even with everything he found is pointing at his suspect, only one question remains: Did he arrest the right person?